Engineered stone litigation, already active across the country, has reached Massachusetts. On October 29, 2026, a plaintiff filed suit in Middlesex County Superior Court against 28 defendants, including manufacturers, sellers, and distributors of engineered stone products. The plaintiff alleges silicosis and other lung conditions from fabricating and cleaning up engineered stone.
Similar suits are pending in California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Kentucky, Florida, Colorado, and Texas. No MDL or coordinated docket exists, so each case proceeds on its own facts and under its own state’s law. For defendants, that means the strategy has to be built case by case, and early decisions about product identification, warnings evidence, and the employer’s conduct often shape the outcome.
The Product Is Not the Hazard.
Crystalline silica is one of the most common substances on earth. It is found in sand, soil, granite, concrete, brick, and glass. Silica dust is created when any of these materials is cut, ground, drilled, or crushed, whether the material is engineered stone, natural stone, or ordinary construction materials.
Engineered stone is manufactured by binding crushed quartz with polymer resins and pigments. A finished slab does not release respirable crystalline silica sitting in a showroom or installed in a kitchen. Respirable dust is generated only when the stone is cut, grinded, or polished.
The controls for silica dust are well established and include wet cutting, local exhaust ventilation, and proper respiratory protection effectively control exposure. OSHA’s 2016 respirable crystalline silica standard sets a permissible exposure limit of 50 micrograms per cubic meter averaged over an eight-hour day and requires employers to implement these controls.
Defenses That Are Working
1. The product was not defective.
In May 2025, a California jury returned a defense verdict for Caesarstone in a wrongful death case brought by the widow of a 46-year-old fabricator. The case went to the jury on negligence and design defect, along with Caesarstone’s defenses of superseding cause and product misuse. The jury found Caesarstone was not negligent and that its slabs were not defectively designed. The evidence showed that the slabs themselves contain no respirable crystalline silica; that dust is created only during fabrication and endangers workers only when standard industrial hygiene practices and Cal-OSHA silica regulations are ignored.
2. Adequate warnings were given.
Manufacturers’ labels and safety data sheets identify silica dust as a hazard and warn specifically against dry cutting. At trial in Colorado, manufacturers showed that their labels clearly communicated that dry-cutting could cause fabricators to inhale the particles that cause silicosis. This defense has gained real traction: in at least two California trials, judges granted nonsuit on failure-to-warn and punitive damages claims before the cases ever reached a jury.
3. Sophisticated intermediary and sophisticated user doctrines.
Engineered stone is sold to professional fabricators, businesses that are legally required to understand and control silica hazards in their shops. California adopted the sophisticated intermediary doctrine in Webb v. Special Electric (2016), under which a supplier discharges its duty to warn by conveying adequate warnings to the purchaser, or selling to a sufficiently sophisticated purchaser, and reasonably relying on that purchaser to warn its workers. Defendants should be prepared to show both the purchaser’s knowledge and their actual, reasonable reliance on it. Massachusetts recognizes a related defense: in Carrel v. National Cord & Braid Corp. (2006), the Supreme Judicial Court held that there is no duty to warn a sophisticated user of dangers it already knows or reasonably should know.
4. Product identification and distributor liability.
Fabricators typically work with many brands from many suppliers over many years. Plaintiffs must prove that a specific defendant’s product actually caused the injury, and that is often a burden they cannot carry. In California, Color Marble obtained a judgment notwithstanding the verdict after the court found insufficient evidence that Color Marble supplied any of the harmful material and that the plaintiff failed to establish what duty of care a retailer owed. Distributors and sellers named alongside manufacturers should press these issues early.
What This Means in Massachusetts
Massachusetts does not recognize strict liability in tort. Instead, product claims proceed under negligence and breach of the implied warranty of merchantability. That framework offers defendants important tools. Under the warranty theory, a plaintiff who knew of a product’s danger and unreasonably proceeded to use it anyway may be barred from recovery. Under negligence, Massachusetts’ comparative fault statute bars recovery where the plaintiff’s fault exceeds that of the defendants.
How AP&S Can Help
As engineered stone litigation spreads, the defendants who fare best are those who engage early: preserving product identification defenses, assembling warnings and SDS histories. AP&S defends manufacturers, distributors, and suppliers in complex product liability litigation and is prepared to help you respond to these claims in Massachusetts and beyond.