Overview
AP&S represents businesses, public institutions, and individuals seeking to defend favorable judgments, overturn adverse rulings, and resolve unsettled questions of law. Our appellate work includes consequential matters before the Rhode Island Supreme Court, the First Circuit, and other federal and state appellate courts.
Clients engage us both to handle appeals in cases tried by other firms and to continue matters we have litigated from the outset. We also work with trial counsel before judgment to preserve issues and develop the legal arguments that may determine an appeal.
Our appellate record includes successful appeals involving commercial disputes, products liability, constitutional challenges, legislative privilege, insurance coverage, and fiduciary duties.
Our lawyers, including former federal and state judicial clerks and authors on appellate practice, have briefed and argued hundreds of cases. Our experience also includes amicus curiae submissions and proceedings before the United States Supreme Court.
Appeals in Cases Tried by Other Counsel
AP&S handles appeals in cases tried by other firms, either as lead appellate counsel or in collaboration with existing counsel. Our work begins with an independent assessment of the record, the governing standards of review, and the issues most likely to affect the outcome.
Appellate Strategy Before Judgment
We work with trial counsel before judgment to assess significant legal issues, preserve arguments, develop dispositive motions, and address jury instructions and post-trial motions. This work brings an appellate perspective to decisions that may shape both the trial and any subsequent appeal.
Amicus Curiae Briefs
We represent amici curiae seeking to address legal questions with implications beyond the immediate parties. Our experience includes submissions on products liability and matters affecting legal practice. Nicole J. Benjamin, chair of AP&S’s Appellate Practice Group, also serves as Vice Chair of the Amicus and Public Policy committee of the Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel.
Experience
- Soscia Holdings, LLC v. Town of Coventry, No. 26-1272 (1st Cir.): AP&S represents the Town of Coventry and its officials before the First Circuit in an appeal from a federal injunction halting a state court condemnation proceeding. The appeal raises questions the First Circuit has not squarely addressed: whether an injunction directed at a pending state court proceeding is immediately appealable, and whether such an injunction falls within an exception to the Anti-Injunction Act. It also presents issues of abstention. The State of Rhode Island participated as amicus curiae. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal, with John A. Tarantino on brief, and a decision is pending.
- Kniffer v. Rhode Island Airport Corp., Nos. SU-2025-0039-A, SU-2025-0040-A (R.I.): AP&S represents the Rhode Island Airport Corporation before the Rhode Island Supreme Court in defending the State’s condemnation of avigation easements to clear flight hazards near Westerly State Airport. The appeal addresses the State’s eminent domain authority over airport approach zones and whether the Home and Business Protection Act requires enhanced compensation for takings made for traditional public purposes. Daniel J. Procaccini argued the appeal, Colten H. Erickson is on brief, and a decision is pending.
- Stilts, LLC v. State, No. SU-2024-0245-MP (R.I.): In a Fifth Amendment Takings case, AP&S and co-counsel from the Pacific Legal Foundation represent Stilts, LLC before the Rhode Island Supreme Court. Stilts is defending a ruling that Rhode Island’s 2023 Shoreline Access Act took private property without just compensation by opening privately owned coastal land to public use. The Court will decide whether the Act merely codifies background principles of state property law, as the State contends. Daniel J. Procaccini and Colten H. Erickson are on brief, and the appeal is awaiting argument.
- Stilts, LLC v. Coastal Res. Mgmt. Council, No. SU-2026-0028-A (R.I.): AP&S and co-counsel from the Pacific Legal Foundation represent Stilts, LLC before the Rhode Island Supreme Court in defending an injunction against the Coastal Resources Management Council. The injunction bars the Council from conditioning a coastal permit on public beach access and perpetual agency inspections. The appeal raises questions the Court has not yet addressed under the Takings Clause’s unconstitutional conditions doctrine and the Fourth Amendment. Daniel J. Procaccini and Colten H. Erickson are on brief, and the appeal is pending.
- The Dumplings Ass’n, Inc. v. Coastal Res. Mgmt. Council, No. SU-2025-0119-MP (R.I.): AP&S represents SHM Jamestown Boatyard, LLC before the Rhode Island Supreme Court on its granted petition for a writ of certiorari. The boatyard seeks reversal of a decision that vacated the Coastal Resources Management Council’s approval of its marina improvements. The appeal presents an issue of first impression: whether the “raise or waive” rule applies to Administrative Procedures Act appeals. Joshua S. Parks and Colten H. Erickson are on brief, and briefing is underway.
- Conti v. Citizens Bank, N.A., No. 22-1770: AP&S represents Citizens Bank in an appeal from summary judgment in its favor concerning whether the National Bank Act preempts Rhode Island’s requirement that banks pay interest on mortgage escrow accounts. The appeal addresses federal preemption following the Supreme Court’s decision in Cantero v. Bank of America, 602 U.S. 205 (2024).
- Codan Forsikring A/S v. Bogus, No. 25-1770, ___ F.4th ___ (1st Cir. 2026) [full text]: AP&S successfully represented Northeast Marine Pilots, Inc. before the First Circuit, obtaining affirmance of the dismissal of claims seeking to hold the pilots association vicariously liable for a member pilot’s navigational negligence. Resolving an issue of first impression for the First Circuit under the Supreme Court’s longstanding decision in Guy v. Donald, 203 U.S. 399 (1906) (Holmes, J.), the court held that a pilots association may not be held vicariously liable for a pilot’s negligent navigation unless it controls how the pilot performs his navigational duties, and that allegations of employment, incorporation, or ownership share do not establish the requisite control. Joshua S. Parks argued the appeal, and Colten H. Erickson was on brief.
- Vella v. MacD Helicopters, Inc., 189 F.4th 1229 (9th Cir. 2026) [full text]: AP&S submitted an amicus curiae brief for the Product Liability Advisory Council, Inc. in consolidated Ninth Circuit appeals arising from the crash of a Huntington Beach Police Department helicopter. In a matter of first impression, the Court held that the General Aviation Revitalization Act’s 18-year statute of repose contains no “public aircraft” exception and applies to government-owned and government-operated general aviation aircraft. The Court affirmed dismissal of the products liability claims against the manufacturers. Nicole J. Benjamin and Michael A. D’Ippolito III were on brief.
- Williams v. Avco Corp., 360 A.3d 989 (R.I. July 29, 2026) [full text]. AP&S obtained summary judgment on all claims in a wrongful death action arising from an aircraft accident in Mississippi and successfully defended the judgment before the Rhode Island Supreme Court. The Court affirmed on grounds involving the General Aviation Revitalization Act’s statute of repose and the absence of expert evidence of causation. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the summary judgment motions and the appeal, with John A. Tarantino and Daniel J. Procaccini on brief.
- Andrews v. Lombardi, 329 A.3d 1288 (R.I. 2025) [full text]: AP&S secured a significant Rhode Island Supreme Court decision for its client, the City of Providence. The Court held that prejudgment interest under R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-21-10 is unavailable against a municipality on damages awarded for claims alleging constitutional impairment. William M. Dolan argued the appeal.
- Avco Corp. v. Turner, 21-2750, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS 20256 (3d Cir. 2022): AP&S obtained reversal of summary judgment in a breach-of-fiduciary-duty action involving an attorney’s duty of loyalty. The Third Circuit held that the district court had improperly conflated the existence of injury with the amount of damages. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal, with John A. Tarantino on brief.
- Notre Dame (USA) in England v. TJAC Waterloo, LLC, 49 F.4th 13 (1st Cir. 2022) [full text]: AP&S secured confirmation of a foreign arbitration award for the University of Notre Dame (USA) in England in a construction-defect dispute, then successfully defended that judgment before the First Circuit. The Court affirmed confirmation of the tribunal’s damages award. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal with John A. Tarantino on brief.
- Efreom v. McKee, 46 F.4th 9 (1st Cir. 2022), cert denied, 143 S. Ct. 576 (2023) [full text]. AP&S represented Rhode Island’s Governor, General Treasurer and Employees’ Retirement System of the State of Rhode Island in an appeal challenging legislation implementing the pension-reform settlement. The First Circuit affirmed dismissal of the challenge in all respects. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal, with John A. Tarantino on brief.
- Am. Trucking Ass’ns v. Alviti, 14 F.4th 76 (1st Cir. 2021): AP&S represented Rhode Island’s Governor and Speaker of the House of Representatives in an advisory mandamus proceeding concerning legislative privilege. The First Circuit reversed the district court’s ruling on the privilege’s application to subpoenaed documents and testimony in a constitutional challenge to the State’s truck-tolling program. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the petition, with John A. Tarantino and R. Bart Totten on brief.
- In re Paplauskas, 228 A.3d 43 (R.I. 2020) [full text]: On behalf of the Rhode Island Bar Association as amicus curiae, briefed and argued issues of first impression related to the unauthorized practice of law before the Rhode Island Supreme Court, resulting in a decision that drafting deeds and examination of title for marketability constitutes the practice of law. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal.
- Arabian Support & Servs. Co. v. Textron Sys. Corp., 943 F.3d 42 (1st Cir. 2019) [full text]: AP&S obtained summary judgment for Textron Systems Corporation on claims for commissions and offset-related compensation arising from a $640 million weapons sale, then successfully defended the judgment before the First Circuit. The court rejected reliance on alleged oral commission promises inconsistent with written agreements and held that Chapter 93A claim concerned conduct primarily outside Massachusetts. John A. Tarantino argued the appeal, with Nicole J. Benjamin on brief.
- Cranston Firefighters, IAFF Local 1363 v. Raimondo, 880 F.3d 44 (1st Cir. 2018) [full text]. On behalf of Rhode Island’s Governor, General Treasurer and the Employees’ Retirement System of the State of Rhode Island, AP&S obtained the First Circuit’s affirmance of the district court’s dismissal of constitutional challenges brought by a municipality’s public safety employees to pension reform legislation enacted by the Rhode Island General Assembly in 2011. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal with John A. Tarantino on brief.
- Clifford v. Raimondo, 184 A.3d 673 (R.I. 2018) [full text]: AP&S successfully defended approval of a class action settlement resolving constitutional challenges to Rhode Island’s pension reforms and preserving approximately 92 percent of the savings generated by the challenged legislation. AP&S represented Rhode Island’s Governor, General Treasurer, and Employees’ Retirement System of Rhode Island, AP&S briefed and argued the appeal brought by settlement objectors. John A. Tarantino argued the appeal with Joseph Avanzato, Nicole J. Benjamin, and Patricia K. Rocha on brief.
- In re Bagdis Living Trust Agreement, 136 A.3d 1122 (R.I. 2016) [full text]: Briefed and argued an issue of first impression in the Rhode Island Supreme Court, resulting in the recognition of a statutory right for trustees to recover their attorneys’ fees when a trust beneficiary refuses, without any basis, to release the trustee of his or her fiduciary duties. Nicole J. Benjamin argued the appeal.
- Dauray v. Mee, 109 A.3d 832 (R.I. 2015) [full text]: AP&S obtained summary judgment for charitable corporations in three separate actions alleging undue influence and fraud concerning donations made through will, trusts, and lifetime gifts. The Rhode Island Supreme Court affirmed all three judgments. Joseph Avanzato argued the appeal, with Nicole J. Benjamin on brief.
- Irons v. Rhode Island Ethics Commission, 973 A.2d 1124 (R.I. 2009): In a matter of first impression, the Rhode Island Supreme Court held that AP&S’ client, the former President of the Rhode Island Senate, was immune from Ethics Commission prosecution because the charges against him stemmed from how he voted on legislation. Under the speech in debate clause of the Rhode Island Constitution, legislators are immune from prosecution on how they vote on legislation or participate in legislative activities.
- State of Rhode Island v. Lead Industries Association, et al., 951 A.2d 428 (R.I. 2008): In the longest jury trial in Rhode Island history—the Attorney General’s landmark lead-litigation public nuisance case—AP&S successfully defended Atlantic Richfield Company, the only defendant found not responsible by the jury at trial. AP&S also represented Atlantic Richfield successfully on appeal, where the Rhode Island Supreme Court affirmed the verdict in the company’s favor. AP&S also argued on behalf of all defendants with respect to their attacks on the Attorney General’s contingency-fee agreement with private counsel. John Tarantino argued the appeal.
- DeCesare v. Lincoln Benefit Life Co., 852 A.2d 474 (R.I. 2004): A watershed decision on Rhode Island class action law in which the Supreme Court clarified the legal parameters that determine when and how a nationwide plaintiff class may be certified to pursue both injunctive and monetary relief. Geoffrey W. Millsom argued the appeal.
- Textron Inc. v. Aetna Casualty and Surety Co., 754 A.2d 742 (R.I. 2000) [full text]: The Rhode Island Supreme Court held, in favor of AP&S’s client, the so-called pollution exclusion clause in commercial general liability policies to be ambiguous and thereby afforded coverage to policyholders who do not intentionally or recklessly pollute the properties of others.
- Textron Inc. v. Aetna Casualty and Surety Co., 723 A.2d 1138 (R.I. 1999) [full text]: The Rhode Island Supreme Court determined the trigger for coverage for insurance policies in environmental damage cases, and also determined the kinds of expert and scientific/technical evidence that could be used to trigger policies, in favor of AP&S’ client.
- DiPetrillo v. The Dow Chemical Company, 729 A.2d 677 (R.I. 1999) [full text]: The Rhode Island Supreme Court adopted the Daubert-type standards for the admission of scientific evidence and established the procedure in Rhode Island courts for pretrial Daubert hearings. John A. Tarantino argued the appeal.
Case Studies
AP&S Limits Discovery and Secures Appellate Win in Long-Tail Aviation Products Litigation
AP&S Successfully Defends Client in Longest Jury Trial in Rhode Island History and on Appeal in Landmark Lead Pigment Public Nuisance Case
AP&S Successfully Defends Charitable Organizations in $60 Million Litigation
Seminars
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, Recent Developments in Courts and Civil Procedure, RI Bar Association CLE, Annually 2014-2024.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Can You DIG It? What in-house and outside counsel need to know about dual-purpose attorney-client communications after the U.S. Supreme Court’s dismissed as improvidently granted order in In re Grand Jury, Rhode Island Bar Association CLE, October 2023.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Moderator, Coming Together: An Open Conversation with O. Rogeriee Thompson, Circuit Judge of the First Circuit of Appeals and John J. McConnell, Jr., Chief Judge of the District of Rhode Island, Rhode Island Bar Association CLE, June 2021.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, Supreme Ghostbusters, Email Gatekeepers and Other Issues of First Impression, Rhode Island Supreme Court Round-Up Seminar, July 2015.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, Appellate Practice CLE, RI Bar Association Annual Meeting, June 2014.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, The Court’s Role in Managing High Profile Civil and Criminal Cases, American College of Trial Lawyers’ Regional Meeting, June 2014.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, May It Please The Court: Best Practices for Rhode Island Supreme Court Appeals, CLE, September 2011, March 2012.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Speaker, Rhode Island Appellate Practice: Some Tips and Pitfalls, CLE, April 2011.
- Jeffrey K. Techentin, Speaker, Nuts and Bolts of Preparing an Appeal, RI Bar Association Seminar.
Best Lawyers®
- Rated Tier 1 Metropolitan “Best Law Firm” by Best Lawyers®.
- Nicole J. Benjamin, Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year for Appellate Practice in Providence in 2023 and 2026.
